Nu Holdings: Why 22.5% NIM Isn't a Profit Margin
Nu reported a 22.5% net interest margin in Q3, but just 12.1% after credit costs. Learn why lending margins need a risk adjustment.
MOATEY Team
MOATEY Research
Nu Holdings, the parent company of Nubank, reported another quarter of substantial growth last week. Gross revenue reached $6.3 billion under its managerial reporting presentation, net income increased to approximately $1.1 billion, and its credit portfolio expanded to $41.6 billion.
One of the most interesting figures was its 22.5% net interest margin. For investors accustomed to analyzing traditional companies, that might sound like an exceptionally strong profit margin. But a net interest margin measures something different, and Nu's own results provide a useful illustration of why the distinction matters.
After accounting for credit costs, Nu reported a risk-adjusted net interest margin of 12.1%. The difference is substantial. It shows why investors cannot evaluate a lender's earning power simply by examining the interest it receives relative to its funding costs.
What net interest margin actually measures
Most companies generate revenue by selling products or services. Banks and other lenders have an additional economic activity: they collect funds from depositors and other sources, then deploy those funds into loans and interest-earning investments.
The difference between interest income and the cost of funding those assets is called net interest income. Net interest margin, or NIM, expresses that income relative to the lender's average interest-earning assets, generally on an annualized basis.
Consider a simplified lending business with $100 million of average interest-earning assets. Suppose it earns $12 million of interest annually while paying $4 million in funding costs. Net interest income would be $8 million, producing an 8% net interest margin.
That 8% is not the company's net profit margin. It excludes credit losses, employee compensation, technology expenses, administration, taxes and other costs. It describes the return generated from interest activities before several important economic obligations.
Nu's latest earnings presentation filed with the SEC provides a real-world example. The company reported $3.872 billion of quarterly net interest income and an annualized NIM of 22.5%.
That is evidence of substantial income generation from its interest-earning assets. But it is only the first stage of the profitability analysis.
Why credit costs change the interpretation
Lending businesses earn interest because they provide capital while accepting risks. One of those risks is that borrowers may fail to repay some or all of their obligations.
Credit costs therefore represent an essential part of the economics of lending. They can include allowances for expected credit losses recognized before borrowers ultimately default. These estimates reflect the lender's assessment of future losses and are not identical to cash losses realized during the period.
Nu reported approximately $1.789 billion in quarterly credit costs alongside its $3.872 billion of net interest income. After incorporating those costs, its risk-adjusted NIM was 12.1%, substantially below the headline 22.5% NIM.
Nu defines risk-adjusted NIM as annualized net interest income less credit costs, divided by its average interest-earning balance-sheet assets. The two ratios use a comparable asset denominator, which makes the difference between them informative.
In simplified terms, the first ratio asks how effectively the institution earns interest after paying for funding. The second asks how much of that income remains after recognizing the expected cost of borrowers not repaying.
Neither measure is a complete net profit margin. Even risk-adjusted NIM excludes other operating expenses and taxes. It is best understood as another stage in the economics of providing credit.
A higher lending yield is not always better
This distinction becomes important when comparing lenders with different customer bases. A bank offering relatively low-risk secured mortgages may earn a lower interest yield than a company providing unsecured consumer loans or revolving credit-card balances.
The higher-yielding portfolio might initially appear more attractive. But the lender accepting greater borrower risk may also experience higher delinquencies and credit losses.
What matters is how much economic return remains after accounting for those differences.
A lender generating a 20% net interest margin with 12 percentage points of annualized credit costs does not necessarily have better lending economics than one generating a 12% NIM with only 2 percentage points of credit costs. In that simplified comparison, the second lender retains more risk-adjusted interest income relative to its assets.
These hypothetical figures do not establish how either business should be valued. Capital requirements, loan duration, operating expenses, taxes and funding resilience also matter. The example merely illustrates why the highest headline lending yield does not automatically represent the most attractive economic outcome.
Nu's results reinforce this point. Its credit portfolio grew 33% year over year on a foreign-exchange-neutral basis, including 39% growth in unsecured lending. The expansion creates more opportunities to earn interest, but it also increases the importance of underwriting discipline and credit-loss expectations.
Why Nu reported two different risk-adjusted margins
Nu's third-quarter results contain another useful analytical detail. Reported risk-adjusted NIM declined from 12.4% in the second quarter to 12.1% in the third quarter.
However, management also presented a measure excluding identified non-recurring items. Under that calculation, recurring risk-adjusted NIM increased from 11.9% to 12.7% over the same period.
The difference reflects unusual items moving in opposite directions between quarters. During Q2, a benefit associated with the Desenrola program contributed approximately 55 basis points to reported risk-adjusted NIM. During Q3, a one-time charge related to receivables acquired from payment institutions subsequently placed under liquidation by Brazil's central bank reduced the measure by approximately 63 basis points.
Management stated that the Q3 charge was unrelated to the credit performance of its customer loan portfolio.
Removing these items produces a different picture of the underlying sequential trend. On the reported basis, risk-adjusted NIM deteriorated slightly. On management's adjusted basis, it improved.
Neither comparison should automatically replace the other. The reported calculation includes the economic effects recognized during the period. The adjusted calculation attempts to isolate results management considers more representative of recurring operations.
Investors should examine the specific adjustments and their frequency rather than treating an adjusted number as inherently superior. An unusual loss still has consequences, and an item described as non-recurring deserves closer scrutiny if similar adjustments appear repeatedly.
The changing loan portfolio complicates the credit picture
Nu's credit portfolio has also been changing in composition. Management reported that interest-earning balances represented 61% of the total portfolio during Q3, compared with 59% in the preceding quarter and 44% three years earlier.
This matters when interpreting delinquency rates. Credit-card transactions repaid in full and interest-bearing loans can have very different repayment characteristics. As the share of interest-bearing balances expands, delinquency measured across the total portfolio can change partly because the denominator contains a different mix of credit exposure.
Nu reported that the proportion of its total portfolio more than 90 days past due increased from 6.9% to 7.3% between Q2 and Q3. When measured against interest-earning balances specifically, the corresponding rate increased from 11.6% to 12.1%.
Those figures should not be dismissed as merely a statistical effect. Both rates increased sequentially, and the credit performance of the underlying portfolio remains important.
However, the distinction illustrates why investors should understand how a metric is calculated. A changing loan mix can affect the relationship between headline delinquency ratios and the underlying risk of the assets generating interest income.
Nu's reported expected-credit-loss allowance also increased during the quarter, from approximately $6.6 billion to $7.1 billion. Portfolio growth and deliberate expansion into riskier lending segments contributed to that movement.
The broader analytical question is whether additional interest income adequately compensates the company for the credit losses, capital requirements and operating costs associated with expanding the portfolio.
Funding costs provide another part of the equation
Credit risk is one side of the lending business. Funding costs are another.
Nu reported deposits of $47.5 billion at the end of Q3, up 19% year over year on a foreign-exchange-neutral basis. Its consolidated cost of deposits declined to 87% of the relevant interbank benchmark rates, compared with 89% a year earlier.
That is potentially valuable because a lender that can attract and retain customer deposits at relatively favorable costs may have more room to generate net interest income.
A durable ability to obtain low-cost funding can contribute to a structural cost advantage, although that requires evidence that the benefit persists through changing interest-rate and competitive environments.
For Nu, the expanding customer base and deposit franchise create opportunities to improve funding economics. But the available figures alone do not establish that the advantage is permanent. Deposit pricing, competitive offers, regulatory requirements and customer behavior can all change.
It is also important not to compare the reported 87% benchmark-relative funding cost directly with Nu's 22.5% NIM. They are different measures with different denominators.
Investors need to examine the yields on assets, the actual cost of funding, the credit losses associated with those assets and the operating costs required to serve customers before reaching conclusions about sustainable profitability.
What MOATEY sees beyond the headline growth
The latest MOATEY assessment classifies Nu Holdings as a Cyclical company and currently assigns a Poor rating with an overall assessment of 22 out of 95 points.
The framework gives Nu 11 of 15 Growth points. Its five-year revenue growth measure is 55.73%, while its adjusted five-year free-cash-flow growth measure is negative at -14.09%. These measures describe different aspects of the company's development and should not be interpreted as interchangeable.
MOATEY also gives Nu 0 of 15 Financial Health points and 6 of 20 Moat points. The company's current valuation assessment receives no points because the framework applies restrictions related to cyclical earnings and insufficient evidence of a clear, lasting competitive advantage.
That is an important qualification. The absence of valuation points should not be interpreted as a definitive conclusion that Nu's shares are overpriced. MOATEY's detailed explanation explicitly recognizes potential upside under its valuation assumptions while noting that the relevant restrictions prevent valuation points from contributing to the overall assessment.
Nor should the Financial Health assessment be read as a direct estimate of Nu's regulatory capital adequacy or probability of default. Financial institutions have distinctive balance sheets, and individual credit, liquidity and capital measures require industry-specific interpretation.
These are systematic MOATEY framework observations, not forecasts of Nu's future loan losses or investment returns. The underlying methodology and supporting historical evidence can be inspected in the MOATEY factsheet and documentation.
The useful distinction is that rapid growth does not remove the need to evaluate credit quality, financial resilience, competitive advantage and valuation separately.
What investors should monitor next
Nu's latest quarter offers evidence of continued customer growth and substantial profitability. The company reached approximately 143 million customers, generated record net income of $1.1 billion and maintained a reported return on equity of approximately 32%.
Those figures are encouraging, but they do not eliminate the importance of credit costs. As Nu expands its lending portfolio, investors should watch whether risk-adjusted NIM remains attractive and whether credit losses develop in line with the assumptions reflected in current reserves.
Another useful comparison is the relationship between the interest-earning share of the portfolio and delinquency rates. As more balances generate interest, reported revenue opportunities increase, but the composition of the portfolio can also affect credit risk.
Funding costs deserve equal attention. Continued deposit growth at favorable relative costs could support lending economics, while more expensive funding could reduce the income remaining after interest expenses.
Finally, management's recurring risk-adjusted NIM should be monitored alongside the reported figure. Adjustments can clarify unusual events, but long-term investors should expect a convincing explanation of each adjustment and remain aware of the full economic consequences.
Want to follow how Nu's lending growth, financial health and valuation develop over time?
Create a free MOATEY account and unlock up to 10 companies. You can view their current fundamental analysis, add them to your watchlist or portfolio, and follow important Events such as rating, classification and underlying evidence changes.
The lesson for long-term investors
Nu's 22.5% net interest margin illustrates how powerful the lending business can appear when interest income is considered after funding costs but before credit losses. The 12.1% risk-adjusted margin adds the next important layer by incorporating the expected cost of borrowers not repaying.
Neither figure, however, tells the entire profitability story. Operating expenses, capital requirements, taxes, changing customer behavior and the durability of funding conditions still affect what shareholders ultimately earn.
The same principle applies to other lenders. An attractive interest spread is useful, but its economic value depends on the risks the institution accepts to generate it.
For a long-term investor, the objective is not to find the highest net interest margin. It is to understand how much sustainable return remains after the costs and risks of producing that margin are properly considered.
